In recent years, the rise of predatory journals has become a significant concern for many academics, including lecturers and students. The sincere intention to publish scholarly work can easily backfire academically and financially if one unknowingly submits to a non-credible journal. So, how can you tell the difference between a predatory journal and a credible one?
This article outlines six essential differences to help you choose a trustworthy and reputable publication outlet.
1. Peer Review Process
- Credible Journals:
Have a precise, rigorous, and structured peer-review process. Independent reviewers read, evaluate, and provide feedback to improve the quality of the article. This process can take several weeks or even months.
They often skip the review process or treat it as a mere formality. Many journals accept articles within 1–2 days without providing any comments or suggestions. Their main goal is profit, not quality.
2. Transparency of Fees
- Credible Journals:
Clearly explain any publication fees upfront (such as article processing charges or APCs), including what services are provided. Some reputable journals are even free to publish in.
- Predatory Journals:
Publishers often hide fees or disclose them only after accepting the article, then add vague charges like “indexing,” “editing,” or “DOI registration.”
3. Website and Information Quality
- Credible Journals:
Maintain professional, well-organized websites with complete and updated information—scope, editorial board, indexing status, templates, and author guidelines.
- Predatory Journals:
They tend to have poorly designed, outdated websites riddled with typos. They often lack essential information and, sometimes, list editors without permission or use fake identities.
4. Indexing and Accreditation
- Credible Journals:
Are officially indexed in reputable databases like DOAJ, Scopus, Web of Science, or SINTA (for national journals). You can verify this directly through the indexing agency’s website.
- Predatory Journals:
Often, they claim to be indexed in international databases, but these claims are false or unverifiable. Be cautious if they list “Google Scholar” as if it were a prestigious indexing service.
Read More : Why Should Academics Publish in Journals?
5. Email and Communication
- Credible Journals:
Use institutional email addresses and communicate professionally and respectfully. Correspondence tends to be formal and polite.
- Predatory Journals:
They commonly use free email services like Gmail or Yahoo with no official domain. Their tone can be rushed, unprofessional, or overly pushy, especially when asking for payment.
6. Editorial Team Credibility
- Credible Journals:
Have editorial teams composed of scholars and researchers from well-established institutions. Their names, affiliations, and academic profiles are verifiable on platforms like Google Scholar or university websites.
- Predatory Journals:
They often list unclear or unverifiable names and may use stolen photos or images from the Internet. In some cases, they even list researchers without their consent.
Choosing where to publish is not just about getting your paper out quickly but protecting your academic reputation and integrity. By understanding the signs of a predatory journal, you can avoid costly and damaging mistakes.
You can read more articles on writing tips, publishing journals, and getting to know more about scientific journals by visiting us at @jfpublisher and @jakadjournal.
For more information on journal publication, please kindly contact us at +62 813-5858-0584
awidy
