Publishing an article in a scientific journal is a crucial step for academics and researchers. However, the process is not always easy, not all articles are immediately accepted by journal publishers. Many factors contribute to rejection, and understanding these reasons can help improve publication chances. Here are seven main reasons why articles are often rejected by journal publishers:

1. Not Aligned with the Journal’s Scope

Each journal has a specific scope and focus. Articles that are not relevant to the journal’s subject matter will be rejected outright, even before the review stage. Therefore, it is essential to select a journal that aligns with your research field.

2. Low Quality and Lack of Originality

Reputable journals only accept articles that contribute new knowledge to the field. If an article is deemed unoriginal, lacks novelty, or merely repeats previous research without deep analysis, it is likely to be rejected.

3. Plagiarism or High Content Similarity

Journal publishers use plagiarism detection software to ensure the originality of submissions. If the similarity index is too high or there are signs of duplication from previous publications, the article will be automatically rejected.

4. Weak Research Methodology

Unclear methodology, invalid data, or weak analysis can lead to article rejection. Scientific journals prioritize research with solid and accountable methodological approaches.

Read More : How to Identify Discontinued Journals

5. Noncompliance with Structure and Formatting Guidelines

Each journal has specific writing guidelines, including reference formatting, article length, and content structure. Following these guidelines is essential, as failure to comply may result in delays or rejection of the article. The editor often returns or directly rejects articles that fail to comply with these standards.

6. Language and Grammar Errors

Poor language use, unclear sentences, or numerous grammatical errors can undermine the credibility of an article. International journals usually require well-structured and grammatically correct academic English.

7. Failure to Follow Reviewer Suggestions

If authors ignore reviewers’ comments or fail to revise their articles as suggested, journals may reject them at the revision stage. Always respond to reviewer feedback appropriately and make the necessary improvements.

Understanding the reasons for article rejection can help researchers prepare a better manuscript before submission. Ensure that your article offers novelty, employs a strong methodology, and adheres to journal guidelines to increase acceptance chances. With thorough preparation, publishing in reputable journals becomes more achievable.

You can read more articles on writing tips, publishing journals, and getting to know more about scientific journals by visiting us at @jfpublisher and @jakadjournal.

For more information on journal publication, please kindly contact us at +62 813-5858-0584

awidy